In "Xenophon's Retreat", a superb book, Waterfield starts with the
decisive battle, then works backward and forward. His accounts of
warfare in the 4th century B.C. raise the hair and turn the
stomach. He explores the staggering logistics of moving thousands
of men, slaves, concubines and animals, tons of supplies, armor and
weapons, over alien territories. His hunches are reasonable and his
storytelling gripping.--John Timpane"Philadelphia Inquirer"
(05/06/2009)
Mr. Waterfield, unlike his ancient source, tells the story briskly
and vividly. Reading his account of the march is like hearing a
record that used to sound like sludge finally set to the right rpm.
But Mr. Waterfield...goes easy on his favored Greeks, whom he views
as trying to live virtuously in a world that has made it
impossible, forgetting somehow that mercenaries like Xenophon's men
were the ones who made it impossible. Xenophon had his chance to
live virtuously. He had been loosely associated with Socrates and
so knew the basic outline of the virtuous life. But Xenophon grew
bored and headed east--to present-day Iraq, which has never been a
good place to go if you're bored or looking to live
virtuously.--Brendan Boyle "New York Sun "
The "Anabasis" is a good place to begin understanding the Greek and
thus Western way of inventing the East and defining ourselves
through contrast, and sometimes conflict, with it. Waterfield's
book is a good place to begin understanding the "Anabasis". On the
armature of Xenophon's narrative Waterfield sculpts a readable,
accurate recounting of the Greek march up-country and the retreat
after Cunaxa...I wish I had known this book when I read the
"Anabasis" with my students in the fall of 2006. When I read it
again in 2007, my students will learn much from Waterfield's
accessible introduction.--Lee T. Pearcy "Bryn Mawr Classical Review
"
you're bored or looking to live virtuously.
Ask a Question About this Product More... |