Alternative Press - "[T]he spirit of having all five members in a room clashing creatively -- along with the steady hands of punk-rock super-producers Bill Stevenson and Jason Livermore and mixing legend Andy Wallace -- has resulted in some of A Day To Remember's most forward-thinking, engaging and all-around exemplary songs to date."

Clash (magazine) - "'Night Terrors' rocks up to the party with a lopsided grin and a picnic hamper of hard drugs. Like his past albums' bloated highlights `The Pheasant' and `Solstice', this winding nine minute-er demonstrates that Berry is at his best when he goes wildly off script."